Have you put the Goodyears on your car yet? I still have OE tires on mine. Still have not replaced the original tires from when I got the RS in 2016. I am finally going to change mine out and going with the Exhilarates as well. Season is about to get cold and I know the Super Sports will not be doing well in the cold. I was going to try the Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4 but didn't see a lot of reviews to feel comfortable enough to go with that set.
I actually ended up with the 245/35R19 Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+. They are a tiny bit bigger than factory, but no issues at all with rubbing. I even did a slight hill hop and didn't bottom out. They're WAY softer than the Cup 2's. I was hoping they would be firmer, but they aren't. Oh well. They're still a great tire. The ride is SO much softer. There seems to be a bit of roll around turns, but as soon as I give it a little gas, the torque vectoring completely mitigates that. Sorry I can't comment on the Goodyear's. I would have them, but ended up getting a great deal on these and took the leap. So far so good.